Trading journal and paper trading: the method to genuinely improve
Also in: FR Français · ES Español · DE Deutsch
Why traders who improve measure everything. What to record, which statistics to track, and how to use a simulator without fooling yourself.
- Without a journal you remember wins and forget mistakes.
- Write down the plan before the trade, not just the result.
- Track 6 numbers: trade count, win rate, gain/loss ratio, expectancy, profit factor, max drawdown.
- Paper trading trains the method, not the emotions: move to real money gradually.
Pilots keep a logbook, elite athletes review every match. Traders who improve do the same: they keep a trading journal. It is not paperwork; it is the tool that turns a series of bets into a measurable, improvable activity.
Why memory lies to us
The human brain remembers selectively. We recall the brilliant 5R trade and forget the seven small losses from impulsive entries. That is confirmation bias combined with hindsight bias (“I knew it”). The result: many traders sincerely believe they are close to profitable while their numbers say otherwise. A journal replaces impressions with facts.
What to record for each trade
Before entry
- Market, direction (long or short) and timeframe.
- The setup: why this trade? (VAL rejection, absorption at support, breakout…)
- Entry price, stop-loss, target, and therefore the planned risk/reward.
- Position size and risk as a % of capital.
After exit
- Exit price, result in currency and in R.
- Exit reason: stop, target, manual exit (and why).
- Plan followed: yes or no. This is the most valuable data point.
- Emotional state: tired, frustrated after a loss, overconfident after a win.
- A screenshot of the chart at entry and exit.
Tip: writing the plan before entry is a filter in itself. If you cannot say in one sentence why you are taking the trade and where it is invalidated, do not take it.
The 6 statistics to track
| Statistic | What it tells you |
|---|---|
| Number of trades | How reliable all the others are (below 30, be careful) |
| Win rate | How often you win |
| Average win / average loss | How big wins are compared with losses |
| Expectancy per trade (in R) | What a trade earns on average: the key number |
| Profit factor | Gross profit ÷ gross loss |
| Maximum drawdown | The worst fall in equity from a peak: your resilience to bad streaks |
We explain the first three and how they connect in our guide to expectancy.
The weekly review
A journal is only worth something if you reread it. Once a week, take thirty minutes to:
- Sort by setup: which one has the best expectancy? Which has been losing money for a month?
- Sort by time of day and market: many traders discover they consistently lose at certain hours.
- Isolate off-plan trades: compare results of “on-plan” and “off-plan” trades. The gap is often dramatic.
- Pick one improvement for the following week. Just one.
Paper trading: useful, if you take it seriously
Paper (simulated) trading means placing fictitious orders on real prices. The benefits are obvious: no financial risk, the ability to test a setup over dozens of trades, and to learn how orders, leverage and stops behave.
The limits are just as real:
- No emotion: losing $1,000 of virtual money does not hurt. Yet fear and greed are the main causes of mistakes with real money.
- Idealised execution: a simulator does not always reproduce slippage, limit-order queues or very illiquid markets.
- Unrealistic size: trading $100,000 virtual when you have $2,000 real distorts everything.
To make it useful, treat the virtual account like a real one: realistic capital, the same risk rules, the same journal. Then go live with very small sizes, and only scale up when live statistics confirm simulated ones.
The Bullmarket simulator keeps the journal for you
The simulator records every trade automatically on real Binance prices: entry, exit, close reason, fees, result in USDT and in R, duration. You can add a setup note to each order, and the statistics tab computes win rate, gain/loss ratio, expectancy, profit factor, maximum drawdown and an equity curve. History exports to CSV for deeper analysis in a spreadsheet.
Educational content only — not investment advice. Trading involves the risk of losing capital.